Conventionalism and the Impoverishment of the Space of Reasons: Carnap, Quine and Sellars

Kenneth R Westphal


This article examines how Quine and Sellars develop informatively contrasting responses to a fundamental tension in Carnap’s semantics ca. 1950. Quine’s philosophy could well be styled ‘Essays in Radical Empiricism’; his assay of radical empiricism is invaluable for what it reveals about the inherent limits of empiricism. Careful examination shows that Quine’s criticism of Carnap’s semantics in ‘Two Dogmas of Empiricism’ fails, that at its core Quine’s semantics is for two key reasons incoherent and that his hallmark Thesis of Extensionalism is untenable. The tension in Carnap’s semantics together with Quine’s exposure of the severe limits of radical empiricism illuminate central features of Sellars’s philosophy: the fully general form of the myth of givenness, together with Sellars’s alternative Kantian characterisation of understanding; the full significance of Carnap’s distinction between conceptual analysis and conceptual explication, and its important methodological implications; the specifically pragmatic character of Sellars’s realism; and Sellars’s methodological reasons for holding that philosophy must be systematic and that systematic philosophy must be deeply historically and textually informed. This paper thus re-examines this recent episode of philosophical history for its philosophical benefits and systematic insights.

Full Text:



Alston, William P., 1980. ‘Level Confusions in Epistemology’. In: French, Uehling, and Wettstein, eds., Studies in Epistemology. Midwest Studies in Philosophy 5 (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 1980), 135–150; rpt. in: idem. (1989a), 153–171.

Austin, J. L., 1946. ‘Other Minds’. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 20:173–187; rpt. in: idem. (1979), 76–116.

———, 1979. J. O. Urmson, ed., Philosophical Papers, 3d ed. Oxford, The Clarendon Press.

Ayer, A. J, 1935. ‘The Criterion of Truth’. Analysis 3.1–2:28–32.

———, 1936–37. ‘Verification and Experience’. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 37; rpt. in: Ayer (1959), 228–243. (Page references are to the republication.)

———, ed., 1959. Logical Positivism. New York, Free Press.

Benaceraf, Paul, 1973. ‘Mathematical Truth’. Journal of Philosophy 70.19:661–679.

Bergmann, Gustav, 1944. ‘Pure Semantics, Sentences, and Propositions’. Mind (NS), 53.211:238–257.

Bertolet, Rod, 1982. ‘Merril and Carnap on Realism’. Southern Journal of Philosophy 20.3:277–287.

Bird, Graham, 1995. ‘Carnap and Quine. Internal and External Questions’. Erkenntnis 42:41–64.

Black, Max, 1934. ‘The Principle of Verifiability’. Analysis 2.1:1–6.

Bohnert, Herbert, 1963. ‘Carnap’s Theory of Definition and Analyticity’. In: Schilpp (1963), 407–430.

Boxer, Sarah, 1998. ‘At the End of a Century of Philosophizing, the Answer is Don’t Ask’. New York Times 15 Aug., Late Edition – Final, §B, p. 9, column 1.

Bradie, Michael, and William Harms, 2012. ‘Evolutionary Epistemology’. In: E. N. Zalta, ed., The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2012 Edition); epistemology-evolutionary/.

Brandom, Robert, 1981. ‘Semantic Paradox of Material Implication’. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 22.2:129–132.

———, 2002. Tales of the Mighty Dead. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

Campbell, Donald, 1974. ‘Evolutionary Epistemology’. In: P. A. Schilpp, ed., The philosophy of Karl R. Popper (LaSalle, Ill., Open Court), 412–463.

Carnap, Rudolf, 1928a. Der logische Aufbau der Welt. Berlin, Weltkreis. Translated in: Carnap (1969).

———, 1928b. Scheinprobleme in der Philosophie. Berlin, n.p.. Pseudoproblems in Philosophy, R. A. George, tr., in: Carnap (1969), 305–343.

———. 1930–31. „Die Alte und die Neue Logik“. Erkenntnis 1; ‘The Old and the New Logic’, I. Levi, tr., in: Ayer (1959), 133–146.

———, 1931. The Unity of Science. London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.

———, 1932–33a. „Psycholgie in physikalischer Sprache“. Ekenntnis 3; ‘Psychology in Physical Language’, G. Schick, tr., in: Ayer (1959), 165–198.

———, 1932–33b. „Über Protokollsätze“. Erkenntnis 3:215–228.

———, 1932–33c. „Erwiderung auf die vorstehenden Aufsätze von E. Zilsel und K. Duncker“. Erkenntnis 3:177–188.

———, 1934a. Logische Syntax der Sprache. Vienna, Springer. The Logical Syntax of Language, A. Smeaton, tr., London: Kegan Paul, Trench & Truebner, 1937; rpt.: Paterson, NJ.: Littlefield, Adams, and Co., 1959); unless otherwise indicated, page references are to the translation.

———, 1934b. ‘Report of Lectures on Philosophy and Logical Syntax, Delivered on 8, 10 and 12 October at Bedford College in the University of London, by Professor Rudolf Carnap’. Analysis 2.3:42–48.

———, 1936. „Wahrheit und Bewährung“. In: Actes du Congrès international de philosophie scientifique (Paris: Hermann, 1936), 18–23;

———, 1936–37. ‘Testability and Meaning’. Philosophy of Science 3 (1936):419–471, and 4 (1937):2–40F; rpt. New Haven: Whitlock’s, 1954.

———, 1939. Foundations of Logic and Mathematics. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.

———, 1942. Introduction to Semantics. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 1943. Formalization of Logic. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 1944–45. ‘The Two Concepts of Probability’. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 5; rpt. in: H. Feigl and W. Sellars, eds. Readings in Philosophical Analysis (New York: Appelton-Century-Crofts, 1949), 330–348.

———, 1945. ‘Hall and Bergmann on Semantics’. Mind (NS) 54.214:148–155.

———, 1947a. Meaning and Necessity. Chicago, University of Chicago Press (2nd rev. ed.: 1956a).

———, 1947b. ‘On the Application of Inductive Logic’. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 8.1:133–148.

———, 1949. ‘Truth and Confirmation’. In: H. Feigl and W. Sellars, eds. Readings in Philosophical Analysis. (New York, Appleton-Century-Crofts), 119–127.

———, 1950a. ‘Empiricism, Semantics, and Ontology’. Revue International de Philosophie 4:20–40; 2nd rev. ed. in: Carnap (1956a), 205–221.

———, 1950b. Logical Foundations of Probability. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.

———, 1952a. ‘Meaning Postulates’. Philosophical Studies 3.5:65–73.

———, 1952b. ‘[Quine on Analyticity]’, ms. In: R. Creath, ed., Dear Carnap, Dear Van: The Quine-Carnap Correspondence and Related Work (Berkeley, University of California Press), 427–432.

———, 1955. ‘Meaning and Synonymy in Natural Languages’. Philosophical Studies 6.3:33–47; rpt. in: idem., (1956a), 233–247.

———, 1956a. Meaning and Necessity, 2nd rev. ed. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.

———, 1956b. ‘The Methodological Character of Theoretical Concepts’. In: H. Feigl and M. Scriven, eds., Minnesota Studies in Philosophy of Science 1 (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press), 38–76.

———, 1961. „Vorwort zur zweiten Auflage“. In: idem. (1928a), x–xv.

———, 1963a. ‘Intellectual Autobiography’. In: Schilpp (1963), 3–83.

———, 1963b. ‘Replies and Systematic Expositions’. In: Schilpp (1963), 859–1013.

———, 1969. The Logical Structure of the World. R. A. George, tr., Berkeley, University of California Press.

Carus, A. W., 2004. ‘Sellars, Carnap, and the Logical Space of Reasons’. In: A. Awodey and C. Klein, eds., Carnap Brought Home: The View from Jena (Chicago, Open Court), 317–355.

———, 2010. Carnap and Twentieth Century Thought: Explication as Enlightenment. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Chisholm, Roderick, 1957. Perceiving: a Philosophical Study. Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press.

———, 1976. Person and Object: A Metaphysical Study. London, George Allen and Unwin; rpt. London: Routledge, 2002.

Cleeremanns, Axel, 2003. The Unity of Consciousness: Binding, Integration, and Dissociation . Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Coates, Paul. 2007. The Metaphysics of Perception: Willfrid Sellars, Perceptual Consciousness and Critical Realism. London, Routledge.

Cohen, Robert S., 1963. ‘Dialectical Materialism and Carnap’s Logical Empiricism’. In: Schilpp (1963), 99–158.

Creath, Richard, 1976. ‘On Kaplan on Carnap on Significance’. Philosophical Studies 30:393–400.

———, 1985. ‘Carnap’s Scientific Realism: Irenic or Ironic?’ In: N. Rescher, ed., The Heritage of Logical Positivism (Lanham, MD, University Press of America), 117–313.

———, 1987. ‘The Initial Reception of Carnap’s Doctrine of Analyticity’. Nous 21.4:477–499.

———, 1990a. ‘The Unimportance of Semantics’. In: A. Fine, et al., eds., PSA 1990 (East Lansing, MI, Philosophy of Science Association), 2:405–15.

———, ed., 1990b. Dear Carnap, Dear Van: The Quine-Carnap Correspondence and Related Work. Berkeley, University of California Press.

———, 1991. ‘Every Dogma has its Day’. Erkenntnis 35.1–3:347–389.

———, 1992. ‘Carnap’s Conventionalism’. Synthese 93:141–165.

———, 2006. ‘Quine on the Intelligibility & Relevance of Analyticity’. In: R. Gibson, ed., The Cambridge Companion to Quine (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press), 47–64.

Davidson, Donald, 1980. Essays on Actions and Events. Oxford, The Clarendon Press.

———, 2004. Problems of Rationality. Oxford, The Clarendon Press.

Dewey, John, 1930. The Quest for Certainty. London, George Allen & Unwin; New York, Minton Bach.

———, 1938. Logic: The Theory of Inquiry. New York, Holt.

———, 1939. ‘Replies’. In: P. A. Schilpp, ed., The Philosophy of John Dewey (Evanston and Chicago, Northwestern University Press), 515–608.

DiSalle, Robert, 2002. ‘Reconsidering Kant, Friedman, Logical Positivism, and the Exact Sciences’. Philosophy of Science 69:191–211.

Dretske, Frederick I., 1981. Knowledge and the Flow of Information. Cambridge, Mass., MIT/Bradford Books.

———, 1985. ‘Machines and the Mental’. Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association 59.1:23–34.

———, 2006. ‘Information and Closure’. Erkenntnis 64:409–413.

———, 2013. ‘Gettier and Justified True Belief: Fifty Years On’. The Philosophers Magazine 61 (9 July 2013):

Einstein, Albert, 2000. A. Calaprice, ed., The Expanded Quotable Einstein. Princeton, Princeton University Press.

Evans, Gareth, 1975. ‘Identity and Predication’. Journal of Philosophy 72.13:343–63; rpt in: idem., Collected Papers (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985), 25–48.

Feigl, Herbert, 1949. ‘Logical Empiricism’. Rpt. in: H. Feigl and W. Sellars, eds. Readings in Philosophical Analysis (New York, Appelton-Century-Crofts), 3–24.

Fodor, Jerry, and Ernest LePore, 1992. Holism: A Shopper’s Guide. Oxford, Blackwell.

Fogelin, Robert, 2006. ‘Aspects of Quine’s Naturalized Epistemology’. In: R. Gibson, ed., The Cambridge Companion to Quine (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press), 19–46.

Fraassen, Bastian C. van, 1980. The Scientific Image. Oxford, The Clarendon Press.

Friedman, Michael, 1992. Kant and the Exact Sciences. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 1999. Reconsidering Logical Positivism. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

———, 2001. Dynamics of Reason. Stanford, Stanford University Press.

Gibson, J. J., 1966. The Senses considered as Perceptual Systems. London, Allen & Unwin.

Gibson, Roger, 1982. The Philosophy of W. V. Quine: An Expository Essay. Tampa, University of South Florida Press.

———, 1988. Enlightened Empiricism: An Examination of W. V. Quine’s Epistemology. Tampa, University of South Florida Press.

———, ed., 2006. The Cambridge Companion to Quine. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Goodman, Nelson, 1946. ‘The Problem of Counterfactual Condtionals’. Rpt. in: idem., (1983), 1–27.

———, and W. V. Quine, 1947. ‘Steps Towards a Constructive Nominalism’. Journal of Symbolic Logic 12.4: 105–122.

———, 1954, rpt. 1983. Fact, Fiction and Forecast, 4th ed. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

Green, Thomas, 1998. ‘Education as Norm Acquisition’. In: K. R. Westphal, ed., Pragmatism, Reason, and Norms: A Realistic Assessment (New York, Fordham University Press), 145–184.

Grünbaum, Adolf, 1963. ‘Carnap’s Views on the Foundations of Geometry’. In: Schilpp (1963), 599–684.

Gutting, Gary, 2009. What Philosophers Know: Case Studies in Recent Analytic Philosophy. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Haack, Susan, 1993. Evidence and Inquiry. Oxford, Blackwell.

———, 1998. Manifesto of a Passionate Moderate. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.

Hahn, Lewis E., and Paul A. Schilpp, eds., 1986. The Philosophy of W. V. Quine. LaSalle, Ill., Open Court.

Hall, Everett W., 1944. ‘The Extra-Linguistic Reference of Language (II.)’. Mind (NS), 53.209:25–47.

———, 1952. What is Value? London, Routledge & Kegan Paul; New York, Humanities.

———, 1960. Philosophical Systems: A Categorial Analysis. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.

———, 1961. Our Knowledge of Fact and Value. Chapel Hill, NC, University of North Carolina Press.

Hanna, Robert, 2001. Kant and the Foundations of Analytic Philosophy. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Harper, William, 2011. Isaac Newton’s Scientific Method: Turning Data into Evidence about Gravity and Cosmology. New York, Oxford University Press.

Hempel, Carl, 1935a. ‘On the Logical Positivists’ Theory of Truth’. Analysis 2.4:49–59.

———, 1935b. ‘Some Remarks on “Facts” and Propositions’. Analysis 2.6:93–96.

———, 1936. ‘Some Remarks on Empiricism’. Analysis 3.3:33–40.

———, 1979. ‘Scientific Rationality: Analytic vs. Pragmatic Perspectives’. In: T. F. Geraets, ed., Rationality Today – La Rationalité Aujourd’hui (Ottawa, University of Ottawa Press), 46–66.

———, 1988a. ‘On the Cognitive Status and the Rationale of Scientific Methodology’. Poetics Today 9:5–27; rpt. in: idem. (2000), 199–228.

———, 1988b. ‘Provisos: A Problem Concerning the Inferential Function of Scientific Theories’. In: A. Grünbaum and W. Salmon, eds., The Limitations of Deductivism (Pittsburgh, University of Pittsburgh Press), 19–36.

———, 1992. ‘The Significance of the Concept of Truth for the Critical Appraisal of Scientific Theories’. In: W. Shea and S Spadafora, eds., Interpreting the World: Science and Society (Canton, Mass., Science History Publications), 121–129; rpt. in: idem. (2000), 75–88 (with its original title, in which ‘Irrelevance’ occurs instead of ‘Significance’).

———, 2000. R. Jeffrey, ed., Selected Philosophical Essays. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Hintikka, Jaakko, and Gabriel Sandu, 1994. ‘What is a Quantifier?’ Synthese 98:113–129.

Hintikka, Jaakko, 2005. ‘On the Different Identities of Identity: A Historical and Critical Essay’. Language, Meaning, Interpretation 2: 117–139.

———, 2006. ‘Ta Meta Ta Metaphysika: The Argumentative Structure of Aristotle’s Metaphysics’. In: V. Hirvonen, et al, eds., Mind and Modality: Studies in the History of Philosophy in Honour of Simo Knuuttila (Leiden, Brill), 41–55.

———, and Risto Vilkko, 2006. ‘Kant’s Influence on the Development of Modern Logic’. In: H. Lenk and R. Wiehl, eds., Kant Today – Kant Aujourd’hui – Kant Heute. (Münster, LIT Verlag), 112–126.

———, 2007. ‘It All Depends on What “Is” Is: A Brief History (and Theory) of Being’. In: Jon Burmeister and M. Sentesy, eds., On Language: Analytic Continental and Historical Contributions (Newcastle upon Tyne, Cambridge Scholars Publishing), 51–64.

———, and Risto Vilkko, 2007. ‘Existence and Predication from Aristotle to Frege’. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 73.2: 359–377.

Hookway, Christopher, 1988. Quine: Language, Experience and Reality. Cambridge, Polity (Blackwell).

Hunter, Geoffrey, 1995. ‘Quine’s “Two Dogmas of Empiricism”: or The Power of Bad Logic’. Philosophical Investigations 18.4:305–328.

James, William, 1907. Pragmatism: A New Name for some Old Ways of Thinking. London and New York, Longmans, Green, 1907; rpt. in: F. Burkhard, gen. ed., The Works of William James, F. Bowers, ed.; Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press, 1975.

Johnsen, Bredo, 2005. ‘How to Read “Epistemology Naturalized”’. The Journal of Philosophy, 102.2:78–93.

———, 2009. ‘The Argument for Radical Skepticism Concerning the External World’. Journal of Philosophy 106.12:679–693.

———, 2013. ‘Reclaiming Quine’s Epistemology’. Synthese (online: 16 June); doi: 10.1007/s11229-013-0302-4.

Juhos, Béla von, 1934. ‘Empiricism and Physicalism’. Analysis 2.6:81–92.

Kaplan, David, Rolf Eberle and Richard Montague, 1961. ‘Hempel and Oppenheim on Explanation’. Philosophy of Science 28.4:418-428.

Kaplan, David, 1961. ‘Explanation Revisited’. Philosophy of Science 28.4:429-436.

———, 1971. ‘Homage to Carnap’. PSA 1970, Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science (Dordrecht, Reidel) 8:xlv–xlvii.

Kirk, Robert, 1986. Translation Determined. Oxford, The Clarendon Press.

Kraut, Robert, 2010. ‘Universals, Metaphysical Explanations, and Pragmatism’. The Journal of Philosophy 107:590–609

Ladyman, James, Don Ross, Don Spurrett and John Collier, 2009. Every Thing Must Go: Metaphysics Naturalized. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Lance, Mark, 1996. ‘Quantification, Substitution, and Conceptual Content’. Noûs 30.4:481–507.

———, and John O’Leary-Hawthorne, 2008. The Grammar of Meaning: Normativity and Semantic Discourse. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm von, 1702. ‘To Queen Sophie Charlotte of Prussia, On What Is Independent of Sense and Matter’. In: R. Ariew and D. Garber, eds. & trans., Philosophical Essays (Cambridge, Mass.: Hackett Publishing Company, 1989), 186–192.

Lewis, Clarence Irving, 1929. Mind and the World Order: Outline of a Theory of Knowledge. New York, Charles Scribners; rpt. New York: Dover, 1956.

———, 1930. ‘Logic and Pragmatism’. In: G. P. Adams and W. P. Montague, eds., Contemporary American Philosophy (New York, Macmillan), 31–50; rpt. in: idem. (1970), 3–19.

———, 1941. ‘Logical Positivism and Pragmatism’. In: idem. (1970), 92–112.

———, 1946. An Analysis of Knowledge and Valuation. LaSalle, Ill., Open Court.

———, 1970. J. D. Goheen and J. L. Mothershead, Jr., eds., Collected Papers of Clarence Irving Lewis. Stanford, Stanford University Press.

Lotz, John, 1951. ‘Natural and Scientific Language’. Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences 80.1:87–88.

Martin, Richard, 1952. ‘On “Analytic”’. Philosophical Studies 3.3:42–47.

Mates, Benson, 1951. ‘Analytic Sentences’. Philosophical Review 60.4:525–34.

Millikan, Ruth, 1984. Language, Thought and Other Biological Categories: New Foundations for Realism. Cambridge, Mass., MIT Press.

———, 1993. White Queen Psychology: And Other Essays for Alice. Cambridge, Mass., MIT Press.

Murphey, Murray G., 2012. The Development of Quine’s Philosophy. Berlin, Springer.

Murphy, Arthur, 1939. ‘Dewey’s Epistemology and Metaphysics’. In: P. A. Schilpp, ed., The Philosophy of John Dewey (Evanston, Ill., Northwestern University Press), 193–226.

Nelson, R. J., 1997. ‘Proxy Functions, Truth and Reference’. Synthese 111:73–95.

Neurath, Otto, 1931–32. „Soziologie im Physikalismus“. Erkenntnis 2; ‘Sociology and Physicalism’, M. Magnus and R. Raico, trs. In: Ayer (1956), 282–317.

———, 1932–33. „Prokolsätze“. Erkenntnis 3. ‘Protocol Sentences’, G. Schick, tr. In: Ayer (1956), 199–208.

———, 1934. „Radikaler Physikalismus und »Wirkliche Welt«“. Erkenntnis 4:346–362.

———, 1936. „Erster Internationaler Kongress für Einheit der Wissenschaft in Paris 1935“. Erkenntnis 5:377–406.

———, 1940–41. ‘Universal Jargon and Terminology’. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society NS 41:127–148.

Newton, Isaac, 1726. Philosophiae naturalis principia mathematica, 3. rev. ed.. London; rpt. Glasgow: Maclehose, 1878.

———, 1999. The Principia: Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy. I. Bernard Cohen & Anne Whitman, trs., with assistance from Julia Budenz. Berkeley, University of California Press.

Nimtz, Christian, 2002. Wörter, Dinge, Stellvertreter: Quine, Davidson und Putnam zur Unbestimmtheit der Referenz. Paderborn, Mentis.

Olen, Peter, 2012. ‘Sellars in Context: An Analysis of Wilfrid Sellars’s Early Works’. Doctoral dissertation, University of South Florida.

Ospald, Peter, 2010. ‘Michael Friedmans Behandlung des Unterschieds zwischen Arithmetik und Algebra bei Kant in Kant and the Exact Sciences’. Kant-Studien 101:75–88.

Parrini, Paolo, 1976. Linguaggio e teoria. Due saggi di analisi filosofica. Firenze, La Nuova Italia Editrice.

Perkins, Moreland, 1983. Sensing the World. Indianapolis, Hackett Publishing Co.

Pihlström, Sami, and Heikki Koskinen, 2006. ‘Quine and Pragmatism’. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society 43.2:309–346.

Pinker, Steven, 1994. The Language Instinct. New York, W. Morrow & Co.

Popper, Karl, 1971. ‘Conjectural Knowledge. My Solution to the Problem of Induction’. Revue internationale de Philosophie 25.95–96, Parts 1–2:167–197. Rpt. in: idem., Objective Knowledge: An Evolutionary Approach (Oxford: The Clarendon Press, 1972; rev. 2nd ed. 1979), 1–31.

Price, Huw, 2007. ‘Metaphysics after Carnap: The Ghost who Walks?’ In: D. Chalmers, D. Manley and R. Wasserman, eds., Metametaphysics: New Essays on the Foundations of Ontology (Oxford, The Clarendon Press), 320–346.

———, 2011. Naturalism without Mirrors. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Prinz, Jesse, 2005. ‘The Return of Concept Empiricism’. In: H. Cohen and C. Leferbvre, eds., Categorization and Cognitive Science (Amsterdam, Elsevier), 679–695.

Putnam, Hilary, 1995. Pragmatism: An Open Question. London, Wiley-Blackwell.

Quine, W. V. O., 1936. ‘Truth by Convention’. In: O. H. Lee, ed., Philosophical Essays for A. N. Whitehead (New York, Longman’s), 90–124; rtp. in: idem. (1976), 77–106.

———, 1941. ‘Whitehead and the Rise of Modern Logic’. In: P. A. Schilpp, ed., The Philosophy of Alfred North Whitehead (LaSalle, Ill., Open Court), 125–163; rpt. in: Quine (1966), 3–36.

———, 1946. J. G. Buickerood, ed., ‘[Lectures on David Hume’s Philosophy]’. In: D. Føllesdal and D. B. Quine, eds., Confessions of a Confirmed Externalist and Other Essays (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2008), 36–136. (Title supplied by the editor.)

———, 1951a. ‘Two Dogmas of Empiricism’. Philosophical Review 60.1:20–43.

———, 1951b. ‘Semantics and Abstract Objects’. Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences 80.1: 90–96.

———, 1951c. ‘On Carnap’s Views on Ontology’. Philosophical Studies 2.5:65–72; rpt. in: idem. (2004), 249– 256.

———, 1953. ‘Two Dogmas of Empiricism’, rev. ed.. In: idem., From a Logical Point of View (New York, Harper and Row), 20–46.

———, 1960. Word and Object. Cambridge, Mass., M.I.T. Press.

———, 1961. From a Logical Point of View, 2nd rev. ed. New York, Harper & Row.

———, 1966. Selected Logic Papers. New York, Random House.

———, 1969a. Ontological Relativity and Other Essays. New York, Columbia University Press.

———, 1969b. ‘Reply to Chomsky’. In: D. Davidson and J. Hintikka, eds., Words and Objections (Dordrecht, Reidel), 302–311.

———, 1970. ‘Philosophical Progress in Language Theory’. Metaphilosophy, 1.1:2–19.

———, 1973. The Roots of Reference. LaSalle, Ill., Open Court.

———, 1975, ‘Mind and Verbal Dispositions’. In: S. Guttenplan, ed., Mind and Language (Oxford, Oxford University Press), 83–95; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 244–256.

———, 1976. The Ways of Paradox and Other Essays, 2nd rev. ed. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 1981a. Theories and Things. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 1981b. ‘The Pragmatist’s Place in Empiricism’. In: R. Mulvaney and P. Zeltner, eds., Pragmatism: Its Sources and Prospects (Columbia, University of South Carolina Press), 21–40.

———, 1981c. ‘Sellars on Behaviorism, Language, and Meaning’. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 61:26–30.

———, 1985. The Time of My Life: An Autobiography. Cambridge, Mass., MIT Press.

———, 1986a. Philosophy of Logic, 2nd ed. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 1986b. ‘Reply to Manley Thompson’. In: L. E. Hahn and P. A. Schilpp, eds., The Philosophy of W. V. Quine (Chicago and LaSalle, Ill., Open Court), 562–568.

———, 1987. ‘Indeterminacy of Translation Again’. The Journal of Philosophy 84.1:5–10; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 341–346.

———, 1990a. ‘Three Indeterminacies’. In: R. B. Barrett and R. F. Gibson, eds., Perspectives on Quine (Oxford, Blackwell), 1–16; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 368–386.

———, 1990b. ‘The Elusiveness of Reference’. In: M. Sukale, ed., Sprache, Theorie und Wirklichkeit: Studia Philosophica et Historica (Frankfurt am Main, Lang), 13–24; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 352–363.

———, 1991. ‘Two Dogmas in Retrospect’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 21.3:265–274; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 390–400.

———, 1992a. The Pursuit of Truth, 2nd rev. ed. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 1992b. ‘Pressing Extensionality’. In: idem. (2008), 172–175.

———, 1993. ‘In Praise of Observation Sentences’. Journal of Philosophy 90.3:107–116; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 409–419.

———, 1994a. ‘Promoting Extensionality’. Synthese 98.1:143–151; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 438–446.

———, 1994b. ‘Assuming Objects’. Theoria 60:171–183; rpt. in Quine (2008), 449–460.

———, 1995a. From Stimulus to Science. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 1995b. ‘Naturalism; or, Living Within One’s Means’. Dialectica 49.2–4:251–261; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 461–472.

———, 1996. ‘Progress on Two Fronts’. The Journal of Philosophy 93.4:159–163; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 473–477.

———, 2000. ‘Three Networks: Similarity, Implication, and Membership’. In: A. Kanamori, ed., Proceedings of the Twentieth World Congress of Philosophy, vol. 6: Analytic Philosophy and Logic (Charlottesville, Philosophy Documentation Center), 287–291; rpt. in: idem. (2008), 493–497.

———, 2001. ‘Confessions of a Confirmed Extensionalist’. In: J. Floyd and S. Schieh, eds., Future Pasts (New York, Oxford University Press); rpt. in: idem. (2008), 498–506.

———, 2004. R. Gibson, ed., Quintessence: Basic Readings in the Philosophy of W. V. Quine. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

———, 2008. D. Føllesdal and D. Quine, eds., Confessions of a Confirmed Extensionalist and Other Essays. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard University Press.

Reichenbach, Hans, 1938. Experience and Prediction. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.

Rorty, Richard, 1979. Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature. Princeton, Princeton University Press; 2nd expanded ed., 2008.

———, 1986. Consequences of Pragmatism. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press.

Rosenberg, Jay, 2007. Wilfrid Sellars: Fusing the Images. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Roskies, Adina, ed., 1999. ‘The Binding Problem’. Neuron 24:7–125.

Russell, Bertrand, 1905. ‘On Denoting’. Mind 14:479–493; rpt. in: idem. (1994), 4:414–427.

———, 1914. ‘The Nature of Acquaintance’. The Monist 24.1:1–16, rpt in: idem., R. C. Marsh, ed., Logic and Knowledge (London: Allen and Unwin, 1956), 125–174.

———, 1924. ‘Dr. Schiller’s Analysis of The Analysis of Mind’. Journal of Philosophy 19.24:645–651.

———, 1994. J. Passmore, gen. ed., The Collected Papers of Bertrand Russell, 30 vols. London, Routledge.

Ryle, Gilbert, 1949. The Concept of Mind. London, Hutchinson’s University Library.

Schilpp, Paul Arthur, ed., 1963. The Philosophy of Rudolf Carnap. LaSalle, Ill., The Library of Living Philosophers.

———, ed., 1968. The Philosophy of C. I. Lewis. The Library of Living Philosophers 13. LaSalle, Ill., Open Court.

Schlick, Moritz, 1932–33. „Positivismus und Realismus“. Erkenntnis 3; ‘Positivism and Realism’, D. Rynin, tr. In: Ayer (1956), 82–107.

———, 1934. „Über das Fundament der Erkenntnis“. Erkenntnis 4; ‘The Foundation of Knowledge’, D. Rynin, tr. In: Ayer (1956), 209–227.

———, 1935. ‘Facts and Propositions’. Analysis 2.5:65–70.

Sellars, Wilfrid, 1947. ‘Pure Pragmatics and Epistemology’. Philosophy of Science 15.3:181–202; rpt. in: idem. (1980b); ‘PPE’.

———, 1948. ‘Concepts as Involving Laws and as Inconceivable Without Them’. Philosophy of Science 15.4:287–315; rpt. in: idem. (1980b); ‘CIL’.

———, 1949. ‘Language, Rules and Behavior’. In: S. Hook, ed., John Dewey: Philosopher of Science and Freedom (New York, The Dial Press), 289–315; rpt. in Sellars (1980b); ‘LRB’.

———, 1953. ‘Inference and Meaning’. Mind 62:313–38; rpt. in Sellars (1980b), 218–237; ‘IM’.

———, 1956. ‘Empiricism and the Philosophy of Mind’. In: H. Feigl and M. Scriven, eds. Minnesota Studies in Philosophy of Science 1 (Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press), rpt. in Sellars (1963a), 127–196; ‘EPM’.

———, 1963a. Science, Perception, and Reality. London, Routledge and Kegan Paul; New York, Humanities Press; re-issue: Atascadero, Cal.: Ridgeview, 1991; ‘SPR’.

———, 1963b. ‘Empiricism and Abstract Entities’. In: Schilpp (1963), 431–468; ‘EAE’.

———, 1963c. ‘Abstract Entities’. Review of Metaphysics 16:627–671; rpt. in: idem. (1977a), 41–79; ‘AE’.

———, 1963d. ‘Classes as Abstract Entities and the Russell Paradox’. Review of Metaphysics 17:67–90; rpt. in: idem. (1977a), 80–101; ‘CAE’.

———, 1966. ‘The Intentional Realism of Everett Hall’. In: E. M. Adams, ed., Commonsense Realism: Critical Essays on the Philosophy of Everett W. Hall; The Southern Journal of Philosophy 4: 103–15; rpt. in Sellars (1977a), 25–40; ‘IRH’.

———, 1968. Science and Metaphysics: Variations on Kantian Themes. International Library of Philosophy and Scientific Method. London, Routledge and Kegan Paul; New Jersey, Humanities Press; re-issue: Atascadero, Cal.: Ridgeview, 1992; ‘SM’, cited by chapter.¶ number, e.g., ‘SM 3.22’.

———, 1974a. ‘Ontology and the Philosophy of Mind in Russell’. In: G. Nakhnikian, ed., Bertrand Russell’s Philosophy (London, Duckworth; New York, Barnes and Noble), 57–100; ‘OPM’.

———, 1974b. Essays in Philosophy and its History. Dordrecht, Reidel; ‘EPH’.

———, 1977a. J. F. Sicha, ed., Philosophical Perspectives: Metaphysics and Epistemology. Atascadero, Cal., Ridgeview; ‘PPME’.

———, 1977b. J. F. Sicha, ed., Philosophical Perspectives: History of Philosophy. Atascadero, Cal., Ridgeview, ‘PPHP’.

———, 1980a. Naturalism and Ontology. The John Dewey Lectures for 1973–74. Atascadero, Cal., Ridgeview Publishing Co.; rev. ed. 1997; cited by chapter.¶ number, e.g.: ‘NAO 1.32’.

———, 1980b. J. F. Sicha, ed., Pure Pragmatics and Possible Worlds: The Early Essays of Wilfrid Sellars. Atascadero, Cal., Ridgeview; ‘PPPW’.

———, 1980c. ‘Behaviorism, Language and Meaning’. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 61:3–30; ‘BLM’.

———, 1981. ‘Foundations for a Metaphysics of Pure Process’. The Monist 64.1:3–90; ‘FFMP’.

———, 2002a. P. Amaral, ed., Kant and Pre-Kantian Themes: Lectures by Wilfrid Sellars. Atascadero, Cal., Ridgeview; ‘KPT’.

———, 2002b. J. Sicha, ed., Kant’s Transcendental Metaphysics: Sellars’ Cassirer Lectures and Other Essays. Atascadero, Cal., Ridgeview; ‘KTM’.

Sleeper, Ralph, 1986. The Necessity of Pragmatism: John Dewey’s Conception of Philosophy. New Haven, CT, Yale University Press; rpt.: Champaign-Urbana, Ill.: University of Illinois Press, 2001.

Soames, Scot, 2007. ‘Ontology, Analyticity, and Meaning: the Carnap–Quine Dispute’. In: D. Chalmers, D. Manley and R. Wasserman, eds., Metametaphysics: New Essays on the Foundations of Ontology (Oxford, The Clarendon Press), 424–433.

Sober, Eliott, 1975. Simplicity. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Sorell, Tom, G. A. J. Rogers and Jill Kraye, eds., 2010. Scientia in Early Modern Philosophy. Berlin, Springer.

Stich, Steven, 1993. The Fragmentation of Reason: Preface to a Pragmatic Theory of Cognitive Evaluation. Cambridge, Mass., MIT Press.

Stroud, Barry, 1987. The Significance of Philosophical Scepticism. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Tarski, Alfred, 1933. Pojęcie Prawdy w Językach nauk Dedukcyjnych / La notion de la vérité dans les languages des sciences déductives. Prace Towarzystwa Naukowego Warszawskiego, Wydział III Nauk Matematyczno-Fizycznych / Travaux de la Société des Sciences et des Lettrés de Varsovie, Classe III Sciences Mathématiques et Physiques, Nr. 34.

———, 1956. J. H. Woodger, tr., Logic, Semantics, Metamathematics: Papers from 1923 to 1938. Oxford, The Clarendon Press.

Travis, Charles, 2008. Occasion Sensitivity: Selected Essays. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Turnbull, Robert, 1959. ‘Empirical and A Priori Elements in Broad’s Theory of Knowledge’. In: P. A. Schilpp, ed., The Philosophy of C. D. Broad (New York, Tudor), 197–231.

Uebel, Thomas, 1992. Overcoming Logical Positivism from Within. Amsterdam, Rodopi.

Wagner, Pierre, ed., 2012. Carnap’s Ideal of Explication and Naturalism. Baisingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan.

Waller, Bruce, 1978. ‘Carnap and Quine on the Distinction between External and Internal Questions’. Philosophical Studies 33:301–312.

Waismann, Friedrich, 1930–31. „Logische Analyse des Wahrscheinlichkeitsbegriffs“. Erkenntnis 1:228–248.

———, 1945. ‘Verifiability’. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 19:119–150.

White, Morton G., 1950. ‘The Anlaytic and the Synthetic: An Untenable Dualism’. In: S. Hook, ed., John Dewey: Philosopher of Science and Freedom (New York, The Dial Press), 316–330.

Wick, Warner, 1951. ‘The “Political” Philosophy of Logical Empiricism’. Philosophical Studies 2.4:49–57.

Will, Frederick L., Induction and Justification. Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press.

———, 1997. K. R. Westphal, ed., Pragmatism & Realism. Lanham, MD, Rowman & Littlefield.

Williams, Michael, 2012. ‘Knowledge: Authority, Reliability and the Space of Reasons’. Presented in the Sellars Session of the First European Pragmatism Conference, Rome, 19–21 September.

———, 2013. ‘Skepticism, Evidence and Entitlement’. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 87.1:36–71.

Wolff, Michael, 1995. ‘Was ist formale Logik?’ In: C. Fricke, P. König and T. Petersen, eds., Das Recht der Vernunft. Kant und Hegel über Denken, Erkennen und Handeln (Stuttgart, Frommann-Holzboog), 19–31.

———, 2000. ‘Kantische Urteilstafel und vollständige Induktion: Nachtrag zu meiner Kontroverse mit Ulrich Nortmann’. Zeitschrift für Philosophische Forschung 54.1:86–94.

———, 2009. Abhandlungen über die Prinzipien der Logik, 2nd rev. ed. Frankfurt am Main, Klostermann.

———, 2012. ‘Viele Logiken – Eine Vernunft. Warum der logische Pluralismus ein Irrtum ist’. Methodus 7:73–128.

Wolters, Gereon, 2003. ‘Carl Gustav Hempel: Pragmatic Empiricist’. In: P. Parrini, W. Salmon and M. Salmon, eds., Logical Empiricism: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives (Pittsburgh, University of Pittsburgh Press), 109–122.


Kenneth R Westphal
Department of Philosophy Boğaziçi Üniversitesi, İstanbul

(Please see my webpage.)