Russell and Bradley: Rehabilitating the Creation Narrative of Analytic Philosophy

Samuel Lebens


According to Stewart Candlish, Russell and Moore had misunderstood F. H. Bradley’s monism. According to Jonathan Schaffer, they had misunderstood monism more generally. A key thread of the creation narrative of analytic philosophy, according to which Russell and Moore successfully undermined monism to give rise to a new movement is, therefore, in doubt. In this paper, I defend the standard narrative against those who seek to revise it.

Full Text:



Adams, Robert M., 1974. ‘Theories of Actuality.’ Noûs 8: 211–31.

Baldwin, Thomas, 1991. ‘The Identity Theory of Truth.’ Mind 100: 35–52.

Bradley, F. H., 1883. The Principles of Logic. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, and Co.

———, 1897. Appearance and Reality: A Metaphysical Essay, 2nd ed. London: Allen and Unwin, 1916. First published 1897.

———, 1906. ‘On Floating Ideas and the Imaginary.’ Mind 15: 445–72.

———, 1909a. ‘Coherence and Contradiction.’ Mind 18: 489–508.

———, 1909b. ‘On Truth and Coherence.’ Mind 18: 329–42.

———, 1910. ‘On Appearance, Error and Contradiction.’ Mind 19: 153–85.

———, 1911. ‘On Some Aspects of Truth.’ Mind 20: 305–41.

———, 1924. ‘Relations.’ In Bradley (1935), pp. 629–76.

———, 1935. F. H. Bradley: Collected Essays, Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Candlish, Stewart, 1989. ‘The Truth About F. H. Bradley.’ Mind 98: 331–48.

———, 1998. ‘The Wrong Side of History: Relations, the Decline of British Idealism, and the Origins of Analytic Philosophy.’ In Stock (1998), pp. 111–51.

———, 2007. The Russell/Bradley Dispute and Its Significance for Twentieth Century Philosophy. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Candlish, Stewart and Pierfrancesco Basile, 2013. ‘Francis Herbert Bradley.’ In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy,, accessed 9 May 2017.

Edgington, Dorothy, 1997. ‘Vagueness by Degrees.’ In Vagueness, edited by R. Keefe and P. Smith, pp. 294–316. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Ewing, A. C., 1933. Idealism: A Critical Survey. New York: Humanities Press.

Gabriel, Gottfried, 2002. ‘Frege, Lotze, and the Continental Roots of Early Analytic Philosophy.’ In From Frege to Wittgenstein, edited by E. Reck, pp. 39–51. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Griffin, Nicholas, 1998. ‘Did Russell’s Criticisms Miss Their Mark?’ In Stock (1998), pp. 153–62.

Hylton, Peter, 1990. Russell, Idealism, and the Emergence of Analytic Philosophy. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Joachim, Harold, 1906. The Nature of Truth. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Künne, Wolfgang, Mark Siebel and Mark Textor, eds., 1997. Bolzano and Analytic Philosophy. Amsterdam: Rodopi.

Lebens, Samuel, 2008. ‘A Substantive Non-solution to the Problem of Unity.’ Baltic International Yearbook of Logic, Cognition and Communication 4: 1–27.

———, 2017. Bertrand Russell and the Nature of Propositions: A History and Defence of the Multiple Relation Theory of Judgement. New York and London: Routledge.

Milkov, Nikolay, 2000. ‘Lotze and the Early Cambridge Analytic Philosophy.’ Prima Philosophia 13: 133–53.

Moore, G. E., 1919. ‘External and Internal Relations.’ Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 20: 40–62.

Russell, Bertrand, 1903. The Principles of Mathematics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

———, 1906. ‘On the Nature of Truth.’ Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 7: 28–49.

———, 1918. ‘The Philosophy of Logical Atomism.’ Reprinted in Russell (1957), pp. 175–282.

———, 1919. ‘On Propositions: What They Are and How They Mean.’ Reprinted in Russell (1957), pp. 283–320

———, 1957. Logic and Knowledge, edited by R. C. Marsh. London: Allen and Unwin.

Schaffer, Jonathan, 2010a. ‘Monism: The Priority of the Whole.’ Philosophical Review 119: 31–76.

———, 2010b. ‘The Internal Relatedness of All Things.’ Mind 119: 341–76.

———, 2013. ‘The Action of the Whole.’ Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society suppl. vol. 87: 67–87.

Sluga, Hans, 1980. Gottlob Frege. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Smith, N. J. J., 2008. Vaguness and Degrees of Truth. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sprigge, Timothy, 1979. ‘Russell and Bradley on Relations.’ In The Bertrand Russell Memorial Volume, edited by G. W. Roberts, pp. 150–70. London: Allen and Unwin.

Stock, Guy, ed., 1998. Appearance versus Reality: New Essays on Bradley’s Metaphysics. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

van Inwagen, Peter, 2002. Metaphysics. Boulder: Westview Press.

Watling, John, 1970. Bertrand Russell. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd.

Zimmerman, Dean, forthcoming. ‘A Recent Defense of Monism Based Upon the Internal Relatedness of All Things.’ Draft of 7 August 2015.


Samuel Lebens
University of Haifa