"Was There a Sun Before Men Existed?": A. J. Ayer and French Philosophy in the fifties

Abstract

In contrast to many of his contemporaries, A. J. Ayer was an analytic philosopher who had sustained throughout his career some interest in developments in the work of his ‘continental’ peers. Ayer, who spoke French, held friendships with some important Parisian intellectuals, such as Camus, Bataille, Wahl and Merleau-Ponty. This paper examines the circumstances of a meeting between Ayer, Merleau-Ponty, Wahl, Ambrosino and Bataille, which took place in 1951 at some Parisian bar. The question under discussion during this meeting was whether the sun existed before humans did, over which the various philosophers disagreed. This disagreement is tangled with a variety of issues, such as Ayer’s critique of Heidegger and Sartre (inherited from Carnap), Ayer’s response to Merleau-Ponty’s critique of empiricism, and Bataille’s response to Sartre’s critique of his notion of ‘unknowing’, which uncannily resembles Ayer’s critique of Sartre. Amidst this tangle one finds Bataille’s statement that an ‘abyss’ separates English from French and German philosophy, the first recorded announcement of the analytic-continental divide in the twentieth century.

References

H. B. Acton. Philosophy in France. Philosophy, 22(82):161-166, 1947.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0031819100025365

A. J. Ayer & T. Honderich. An Interview with A. J. Ayer. In A. P. Griffiths, editor, A.J. Ayer Memorial Essays, pages 209-226. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1991.

A. J. Ayer. Language, Truth and Logic. London, Gollancz, 1936.

A. J. Ayer. Novelist-Philosopher, Jean-Paul Sartre. Horizon, 12(67):12–26, & 12(68):101-110, 1945.

A. J. Ayer. Novelist-Philosopher, Albert Camus. Horizon, 13(75):155-168, 1946a.

A. J. Ayer. Secret Session. Polemic, 2:60-63, 1946b.

A. J. Ayer. Some Aspects of Existentialism. In F. Watts, editor, H. B. Acton. Philosophy in France. Philosophy, 22(82):161-166, 1947.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0031819100025365

A. J. Ayer & T. Honderich. An Interview with A. J. Ayer. In A. P. Griffiths, editor, A.J. Ayer Memorial Essays, pages 209-226. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1991.

A. J. Ayer. Language, Truth and Logic. London, Gollancz, 1936.

A. J. Ayer. Novelist-Philosopher, Jean-Paul Sartre. Horizon, 12(67):12–26, & 12(68):101-110, 1945.

A. J. Ayer. Novelist-Philosopher, Albert Camus. Horizon, 13(75): 155-168, 1946a.

A. J. Ayer. Secret Session. Polemic, 2:60-63, 1946b.

A. J. Ayer. Some Aspects of Existentialism. In F. Watts, editor, The Rationalist Annual, pages 5-13. London, Watts & Co, 1948.

A. J. Ayer. The Definition of Liberty: Jean-Paul Sartre’s Doctrine of Commitment. The Listener, 44(1135):633-634, 1950.

A. J. Ayer. Jean-Paul Sartre. Encounter, 15(4):75-77, 1961.

A. J. Ayer. On Existentialism. Modern Languages, 48(1):1-12, 1967.

A. J. Ayer. Sartre on the Jews. The Spectator, 211(7317):394-395, 1968.

A. J. Ayer. Reflections on Existentialism. In Metaphysics and Common Sense, pages 203-218. London, Macmillan,1969.

A. J. Ayer. Part of my Life: The Memoirs of a Philosopher. New York, Harcourt Brace Janovich, 1977.

A. J. Ayer. Philosophy in the Twentieth Century. London, Unwinn, 1984.

A. J. Ayer. A Defence of Empiricism. In A. P. Griffiths, editor, A.J. Ayer Memorial Essays, pages 1-16. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1991.

G. Bataille. Un-knowing and its Consequences. A. Michelson, translator, October, 36:80-85, 1986.

G. Bataille. On Nietzsche. B. Boone, translator. London, Continuum, 2004.

G. Bataille, I. Waldberg, & R. Lebel, editors, Encyclopaedia Acephalica. (I. White, D. Faccini, A. Michelson, J. Harman, A. Lykiard, et al., translators.) London, Atlas Press, 1995.

I. Berlin. Review of My Philosophy (And other Essays on the Moral and Political Problems of our Time) by Benedetto Croce. Mind, 61(244):574-584, 1952.

T. Carman. Continental Themes in Analytic Philosophy. In C. V. Boundas, editor, Columbia Companion to Twentieth-Century Philosophies, pages 351-366. New York, Columbia University Press, 2007.

R. Carnap. The Elimination Of Metaphysics Through Logical Analysis of Language (A. Pap, translator). In A. J. Ayer, editor, Logical Positivism, pages 60-81. Glencoe, IL, The Free Press, 1959.

J. Chase & J. Reynolds. Analytic versus Continental: Arguments on the Methods and Value of Philosophy. Durham, Acumen, 2010.

S. Collini. Absent Minds: Intellectuals in Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006.

S. Critchley. Very Short Introduction to Continental Philosophy. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2001.

H. J. Dahms. Neue Sachlichkeit in the Architecture and Philosophy of the 1920s. In S. Awodey & C. Klein, editors, Carnap Brought Home: The View From Jena, pages 357-376. Chicago, Open Court, 2004.

P. J. R. Dempsey. The Psychology of Sartre. Cork, Cork University Press,1950.

V. Descombes. Modern French Philosophy. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1980.

B. Flynn. Merleau-Ponty. In E. N. Zalta, editor, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, <http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/merleau-ponty/>, 2004.

M. Friedman. A Parting of the Ways: Carnap, Cassirer, and Heidegger. Chicago, Open Court, 2000.

G. Gabriel. Carnap’s “Elimination of Metaphysics Through the Logical Analysis of Language:” A Retrospective Consideration of the Relationship between Continental and Analytic Philosophy. In P. Parrini, W. C. Salmon, & M. H. Salmon, editors, Logical Empiricism: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives, pages 30-42. Pittsburgh, University of Pittsburgh Press, 2003.

P. Galison. Constructing Modernism: The Cultural Location of Aufbau. In R. N. Giere, A. Richardson, editors, Origins of Logical Empiricism, pages 17-44. Minneapolis, University of Minnesota, 1996.

S. Glendinning. In the Name of Phenomenology. London, Routledge, 2007.

Gary Gutting. Continental Philosophy of Science. Oxford, Blackwell, 2005.

M. Hammond, J. Howarth, & R. Kent. Understanding Phenomenology. Oxford, Blackwell, 1995.

M. Heidegger. Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics. R. Taft, translator. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1997.

M. Heidegger. Pathmarks. W. MacNeil, editor. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1998.

J. M. Heimonet. Bataille and Sartre: The Modernity of Mysticism. Diacritics, 26(2):59-73, 1996.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1353/dia.1996.0016

J. Himanka. Does the Earth Move?: A Search for a Dialogue Between Two Traditions of Contemporary Philosophy. The Philosophical Forum, 31(1):57-83, 2000.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/0031-806X.00028

A. M. Hollywood. The Philosopher – Sartre – and Me. In Sensible Ecstasy: Mysticism, Sexual Difference and the Demands of History, pages 25-36. Chigago, University of Chicago Press, 2002.

T. E. Hulme. A Note-Book. The New Age, 18(8):186-189, 1915.

T. E. Hulme. A Note-Book. The New Age, 18(10):234-236, 1916.

S. P. James. Merleau-Ponty, Metaphysical Realism and the Natural World. International Journal of Philosophical Studies, 15(4): 501-519, 2007.

S. Käufer. Logic. In H. Dreyfus & M. Wrathall, editors, A Companion to Heidegger, pages 141-155. Oxford, Blackwell, 2005.

E. W. Knight. Literature Considered as Philosophy: The French Example. New York, Macmillan, 1958.

C. A. Mace. Review of The Psychology of Sartre by Peter J. R. Dempsey. Mind, 61(243):425-427, 1952.

B. Magee. Men of Ideas: Some Creators of Contemporary Philosophy. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1982.

A. R. Manser. Sartre and "Le Néant." Philosophy, 36(137):177-187, 1961.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0031819100058022

M. Martin. Sensible Appearances. In T. Baldwin, editor, The Cambridge History of Philosophy, 1870-1945, pages 521-532. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2003.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521591041.044
PMid:14585038

F. Maubert. Francis Bacon, sa dernière interview: “Je poursois le peinture car je sais qu’il n’est pas possible de l’arreter.” Paris-Match, 2242:92-93, 1992.

J. M. E. McTaggart. The Unreality of Time. Mind, 17:457-474, 1908.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mind/XVII.4.457

M. Merleau-Ponty. Phenomenology of Perception. C. Smith, translator. London, Routledge, 2002.

M. Merleau-Ponty. Texts and Dialogues: On Philosophy, Politics, and Culture. H. J. Silverman, editor (M. B. Smith, et al., translators). New York: Humanity Books, 2005.

M. Merleau-Ponty & T. Baldwin. Maurice Merleau-Ponty. London, Routledge, 2004.

H. Meyerhoff. Emotive and Existentialist Theories of Ethics. The Journal of Philosophy, 48(25):769-783, 1951.
http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2021208

I. Murdoch. Sartre, Romantic Rationalist. Cambridge, Bowes and Bowes, 1953.

I. Murdoch. The Idea of Perfection. In The Sovereignty of Good, pages 1-44. London, Routledge, 2001.

A. Oliver. A Few More Remarks on Logical Form. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 99:247-272, 1999.

A. Plantinga. An Existentialist’s Ethics. Review of Metaphysics, 12(2):235-56, 1958.

S. Priest. Merleau-Ponty. New York, Routledge, 2003.

W. V. Quine. Word and Object. M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, MA, 1960.

A. Quinton. Which Philosophy is Modernistic? In Thoughts and Thinkers, pages 39-51. New York, Holmes and Meier, 1982.

J. Rée. English Philosophy in the Fifties. Radical Philosophy, 65:3-21, 1993.

S. Richmond. Sartre and Bergson: A Disagreement about Nothingness. International Journal of Philosophical Studies, 15(1):77-95, 2007.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09672550601143201

B. Rogers. Ayer: A Life. New York, Grove Press, 2002.

K. Romdenh-Romluc. Merleau-Ponty and Phenomenology of Perception. London, Routledge, 2009.

G. E. Rosado Haddock. The Young Carnap’s Unknown Master: Husserl's Influence on Der Raum and Der logische Aufbau der Welt. Aldershot, Ashgate, 2008.

B. Russell. Nightmares of Eminent Persons And Other Stories. London, The Bodley Head, 1954.

G. Ryle, H. A. Hodges, & H. B. Acton. Symposium: Phenomenology. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 11:68-115, 1932.

G. Ryle. Phenomenology vs. The Concept of Mind. In Collected Papers: Critical Essays, Vol. 1, pages 179-196. London, Hutchinson, 1971.

J. P. Sartre. Un nouveau mystique. In Critiques littéraires (Situations I), pages 174-229. Paris, Gallimard, 1975.

J. Skorupski. The Presidential Address: The Legacy of Modernism. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 91:1-19, 1990.

A. Stone. Heidegger and Carnap on the Overcoming of Metaphysics. In S. Mulhall editor, Martin Heidegger, pages 217-244. Aldershot, Ashgate, 2006.

M. Surya, K.Fijalkowski, & M. Richardson. Georges Bataille: An Intellectual Biography. K. Fijalkowski & M. Richardson, translators. London, Verso, 2002.

C. Taylor, & Alfred J. Ayer. Symposium: Phenomenology and Linguistic Analysis. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volumes, 33:93-124, 1959.

N. Trakakis. Meta-philosophy of Religion: The Analytic-Continental Divide in Philosophy of Religion. Ars Disputandi, 7, 2007.

J. Wahl. The Pluralist Philosophies of England and America. F. Rothwell, translator. London, The Open Court Company, 1925.

J. Wahl. Vers le Concret. Paris, Vrin, 1932.

J. Wahl. Nietzsche et la mort de dieu: note a propos du “Nietzsche” de Jaspers. Acéphale, 2:22-24, 1937.

I. Waldberg & Patrick Waldberg. Un Amour Acéphale, Correspondence 1940-49. Paris, Editions de la Différence, 1992.

M. Warnock. The Philosophy of Sartre. London, Hutchinson, 1965.

D. Wiggins. Truth, Invention, and the Meaning of Life. In G. Sayre-McCord, editor, Essays on Moral Realism, pages 127-65. Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 1988. C. Wilson. The Outsider. London, Gollancz, 1956.

D. Zahavi. Phenomenology and Metaphysics. In D. Zahavi, S. Heinämaa, & H. Ruin, editors, Metaphysics, Facticity, Interpretation: Phenomenology in the Nordic Countries, pages 3-22. Dordrecht, Kluwer, 2003.